The Lacanian Review N° 15: "Cut"

 

CONTENTS

 

Editorial

 

Cyrus Saint Avand Paliakoff What Works is the World

Cristina Rose Moro Cut

 

Death Dream
Jacques Lacan, Improvisation désic de mort, cêve et véveil Jacques Lacan, Improvisation: Desire for Death Dream and Awakening

 

Neighborhood
Jacques-Alain Miller, Lanouk du prochain Saint Martin et Salomon
Jacques-Alain Miller, The Love of One's Neighbor, Saint Martin and Solomon

Jacques-Alain Miller, Conspiracy

Im-monde
Guy Briols, The Dignity of Waste
Éric Laurent, Climate Catastrophe, the Anxiety of Scientist Scholars and the Anxiety That is Ours

Geert Hearnack, Residual, You Say?
Jacques-Alain Miller, Some Remarks on Climate Catastrophe
Guy Briole, The Inexorable Logic of War
Jacques-Alain Miller, Some Remarks on the Logic of War

 

Civilization and Anxiety
Daniel Roy, Anxiety and Treatment

Patricia Bosquin-Carez, Believing in It

Réginald Blanchet, Living in Catastrophe
Kattx Langelez-Stevens, Conspiracy Theories: Holding On to the Compass of the Real

Neus Carbonell, Being a Body, Being a Symptom

Jacques-Alain Miller, Some Remarks on Being a Body

 

Spheres
Natalie Wülfing, Making a World

Luc Garcia, CO2 Mon Amour

Dominique Rudaz, Is Bitcoin for Real?

 

Nature / Cut
Robert Buck, Nature / Cut
Donald Moffett, Artist Folio
Jim and Lucia LaVilla-Havelio, Dear René
Paulina Pabocha, Donald Moffett + Nature Cult + The McNay

Jeff Goodell, Why We Love Our Oak Tree

Eileen Myles, RE: Tree Canopy

Marlene McCarty, Earth Life

Grant Worth, Heirloom Mixtape
James Corwell, Exploring the Future of Food: A Global Perspective on the Grapes of Wrath

Rachel Monroe, Ghost Variation

Pete Dandridge, Flight
Suzanne Weaver, The Future Is Undecided
Brett Story, Canary on the Skull

Hannah Fenster, Assertive, but Full of Holes

Lidia Yuknaxitch Neuron
Tenzin Robert Thurman, The Nature Cult Picnic of

Donald Moffett

Luna and Coyote, Welaunee Is Our Nature-Cult

Elizabeth Rogers, Open

​

Editorial

Cyrus Saint Amand Poliakoff, On Repeat

 

The Navel of the Dream is a Hole
Jacques Lacan, À propos de la réponse de Jacques Lacan à Marcel Ritter

Jacques Lacan, Jacques Lacan Responds to a Question from Marcel Ritter

​

Unsocializable Residue
Jacques-Alain Miller, Le salut par les déchets

Jacques-Alain Miller, Salvation Through Waste

 

Fixation. . .

Els Van Compernolle, Between Fixation and Fiction

Christiane Alberti, Variations Around the School One

 

. . . & Repetition

René Raggenbass, “We Speak All Alone. . .”

Alexandre Stevens, Fixation & Repetition

 

The Pass in the School

Jorge Assef, Lacan’s Wager

Florencia F.C. Shanahan, TBC: A Topological Riddle

Dossia Avdelidi, The Psychoanalyst is Not Alone

​

The Physics of Change

Andrew Zwicker & Cristina Rose Laurita, Plasma Doesn’t Know

 

Psychoanalysis in Times of War

Daniel Roy, Preamble
Yuri Volnykh, Coming Together
Mikaël Strakhov, A Tearing Open
Olena Samoilova, A Failed Effort
Gleb Napreenko, At the End of Conformism
Alexandre Fedchuk, A Space for the Analytic Discourse
Inga Metreveli, Of Propaganda
Nikita Moshkin, Finding the Compass
Ève Miller-Rose, Punctuation

 

Covers

​

​

Editorial

Cyrus Saint Amand Poliakoff, She

Ravishment
Jacques Lacan, Hommage fait à Marguerite Duras du ravissement de Lol V. Stein

Jacques Lacan, Homage Done to Marguerite Duras, for the Ravishment of Lol V. Stein

Marcus André Vieira, Love and Ravage

Psychoanalysis and the Feminine Position
Jacques-Alain Miller, Des femmes et des semblants

Jacques-Alain Miller, Of Women and Semblants

 

Masks and Inventions

Christiane Alberti, Introduction to “The Woman Does Not Exist”

Dominique Laurent, The Push-to-the-Woman

Ana Viganó, A Frida Solution: Writing with the Eyes

 

Third Thread
Lynne Cooke and Robert Buck, A Conversation: Of Her Own Making

 

She?

Roger Litten, Bodies Captured by Discourse

Zoe Strimpel, The Word “Woman”

Raquel Cors, A Hole That Allows Breathing

Éric Laurent, Laughing at Norms

 

Untranslatable

Clémentine Bernard, Courtly Love

Sarah Birgani, Poetic of the Feminine

Norbert Leber, Die Unerkennung

Marie-Hélène Brousse, A Barre Over the Discourse of Psychoanalysis

 

The Feminist Does Not Exist

Deborah Gutermann-Jacquet, Body, The Return

Philip Dravers, The Witches of Macbeth

 

Covers

Robert Buck, No Cover

Editorial
Marie-Hélène Brousse, Lacan, the English Language and the USA…
Cyrus Saint Amand Poliakoff, Return Ticket

New World

Pierre-Gilles Guéguen, American Lacan
Jacques Lacan, Of Structure as the Inmixing of an Otherness Prerequisite to Any Subject Whatever
Jacques Lacan, Yale University: Kanzer Seminar
Jacques Lacan, Yale University: Interview with Students
Jacques Lacan, Yale University: Lecture on the Body
Jacques Lacan, Columbia University: Lecture on the Symptom
Jacques Lacan, MIT: Lecture on Topology

Jacques-Alain Miller, North America

Jacques-Alain Miller, Lacan Clinicien
Jacques-Alain Miller, Lacan Clinician

Lacan, At the Moment

Angelina Harari, “Can They Possibly Be My Students?”
Alicia Arenas, The Unconscious, Where Did It Go?
Janet Rachel, English Exodus: Leaving England With Lacan
Thomas Svolos, Meeting the Subjectivity of Our Time
Maria Cristina Aguirre, When the Dust, the Sparks, the Smoke . . .
Isolda Alvarez, A Lacanian Glitch
Robert Buck, Constellation
Alexandre Stevens, With Lacan
Jorge Assef, Pushing the Impossible
Christiane Alberti, Lacan Redivivus: Preface

U.S. Hystories
Josefina Ayerza & Gérard Wajcman, Is Contemporary Art Lacanian?
Ellie Ragland, (Re)-turning to Lacan
Baltimore
Robert Buck, Enjoy!

Editorial
Cyrus Saint Amand Poliakoff, Singularities

​

Singularity – Worth the Sweat

Jacques Lacan, Sur le plaisir et la règle fondamentale
Jacques Lacan, On Pleasure and the Fundamental Rule

​

Signature
Jacques-Alain Miller, La signature des symptômes
Jacques-Alain Miller, Signature of the Symptoms
 

Singularities and the Real
Marie-Hélène Brousse & Pierre-Louis Lions, Singularities, an Analytical Serial: First Episode
 

Pass and the Formation of the Psychoanalyst
Alexandre Stevens, Introduction to the Dublin Day 2021
Dossia Avdelidi, The Most Important One
Florencia F.C. Shanahan, XCEPTION
Anne Béraud, The Sinthome and the Analyst’s Style
Marina Frangiadaki, Of the Use of Supervision in Lacan’s School
Joost Demuynck, A Supervision and An Analysis
Pierre-Gilles Guéguen, The Guarantee for the NLS
Maria Cristina Aguirre, Question of the Guarantee and Supervision
Daniel Roy, Conclusion
 

One, by One

Fourteen, One, by One 

 

Littorals
Marcelo Veras, A Body in Anamorphosis
Elizabeth Rogers, A Feminine Poetic of Movement
Robert Buck, Out There in Nomadland
Kate Briggs, This Body, This Land
 

 

S1
Jean-Claude Maleval and Michel Grollier, Freezing and Thawing of S1 in the Autistic Subject
 

Haute Couture
Gerardo Arenas, Eleven Reflections on the Singular
Peggy Papada, Tracing the Not-All
Alasdair Duncan, Style as a Psychoanalytic Concept
Véronique Voruz, Living Up to One’s Act
 

Editorial
Marie-Hélène Brousse & Cyrus Saint Amand Poliakoff

​

The Mystery of the Papin Sisters and the Knot of Paranoia
Laura Sokolowsky, The Mystery of the Papin Sisters and the Knot of Paranoia
Jacques Lacan, Motifs du crime paranoïaque : le crime des soeurs Papin
Jacques Lacan, Motives of Paranoiac Crimes: The Crime of the Papin Sisters

​

The Clinic of Paranoia
Sophie Marret-Maleval, We’re All Mad, But Not Necessarily Paranoiacs
René Raggenbass, The Moment of the Act As Unpredictable
Dominique Rudaz, Paranoia as “Illness of the Non-Barred Other”

​

A Primary Relation to the Other
Pascale Fari, Paranorama
Jacques-Alain Miller: La paranoïa, rapport primaire à l’autre
Jacques-Alain Miller: Paranoia, A Primary Relation to the Other

​

Guided Paranoia
Sophie Gayard, Inaugural Knot
Lidia Ramírez, I is an other
Irene Kuperwajs, Aerate a Little the Delusion of Meaning
Anne Béraud, From the Paranoid Relation to the

Inconsistency of the Other
Sandra Arruda Grostein, Case S: Fear as Mark of the Relationship with the Other
Alejandro Reinoso, The Un(bearable) Laughter of the Feminine and the Transference

​

The Daemon
Jacques-Alain Miller, Lacan’s Daemon                                                                

The Art of the Paranoid Method
Salvador Dalí, Conquest of the Irrational

​

Political Paranoia: Addiction and Conspiracy
Scott Wilson, QAnon and the Subject of Surveillance Capitalism
Rik Loose, The Politics of a Symptomatology: Paranoia and Addiction

​

Logic of Hatred
Raphaël Liogier and Frédéric C. Baitinger, The Paranoid Logic of Hatred

​

Ideas of Reference
Anna De Filippi, Among Us
Shirley Zisser, Controle as Testimony
Gary Genosko, Introduction to “The Family According to Mony Elkaïm”
Félix Guattari, The Family According to Mony Elkaïm

​

It’s Everywhere
The New Lacanian School, On Paranoia Today

​

Epilogue
Jacques Borie, When Death Alone is Desirable
Shlomo Lieber, Dreams in Times of Corona

Editorial
Marie-Hélène Brousse & Cyrus Saint Amand Poliakoff, The Discipline of the Double Meaning

​

Speaking Being Is Waste
Laura Sokolowsky, Psychoanalysis is an Anti-Initiation
Jacques Lacan, Le phénomène lacanien
Jacques Lacan, The Lacanian Phenomenon

Nature Morte
Gérard Wajcman, The Lives of Nature Morte
Peter Wadhams and Janet Haney, The Iceman Speaketh of the Arctic Death Spiral

​

The End (of Analysis)
Bernard Seynhaeve, The Stars are Aligned
Anna Aromí, Event: The AS and the School One
Domenico Cosenza, The Pass, Between Event and Interpretation
Anne Lysy, What Words, What Body?
Dominique Holvoet, The Pinning of Someone Unplaceable
Anne Béraud, The Indelible Trace
Florencia F.C. Shanahan, Dejar Que Pase…
Patricia Bosquin-Caroz, Pass and Femininity
Jean-Daniel Matet, The Pass, Not Without the School
Véronique Voruz, Our Agalmatic Capital
Alexandre Stevens, From the Pass to Interpretation

​

{Flowers}
Jean-Daniel Matet, Summoned
Anne-Claude Crémieux and Gérard Wajcman, Still Unforeseeable
Chad Abresch, Paradox of Etiology
Steve Woolgar and Janet Haney, Massive Breaching Experiment
Stuart Scott and Janet Haney, Bringing Them the Plague

​

Ventriloquists
Pascale Fari, Presentation
Jacques-Alain Miller, We Are All Ventriloquists
Jacques-Alain Miller, Nous sommes tous ventriloques

​

A Real Science of Life?
Éric Laurent, Preface to the German and Hebrew Editions of The Other Side of Biopolitics
Antonio Di Ciaccia, The Atopia of the Unconscious
Yves Vanderveken, The Unconscious and the Brain: Nothing in Common

​

What to Do With Objects
Lucie de Saint Blanquat and Fred Baitinger, The Littoral Condition of Earth Art
Rik Loose, Art and Psychoanalysis Beyond (Lack-of) Being
Agnieszka Piotrowska and Gustavo Dessal, A Love Life, Still: “Love is essentially deception”

​

Politics: We Are Still Alive?
Guy Briole, A Gray Discourse
Éric Laurent, Europe Through the Ordeal of Hate (Part I)
Éric Laurent, Europe Through the Ordeal of Hate (Part II)

​

Epilogue
Robert Buck, Out of the Blue

Editorial
Marie-Hélène Brousse & Cyrus Saint Amand Poliakoff

​

Aristotle’s Dream

Jacques Lacan, Le rêve d’Aristote
Jacques Lacan, Aristotle’s Dream

​

Another Fire

Jacques-Alain Miller, L’objet perdu du langage
Jacques-Alain Miller, The Lost Object of Language
Marie-Hélène Brousse, “Father Don’t You See I’m Burning?”

​

Eyes Wide Open
Marie-Hélène Brousse, Artifice, the Other Side of Fiction
Carolina Koretzky, Variants of the Desire to Wake Up
Jorge Assef, A Moment of Awakening Beyond the Nightmare

​

Dreams I Cannot Forget
Sérgio Laia, 1, 2, 3 and… (Vivace Version)
Victoria Horne Reinoso, The Flight
María Josefina Sota Fuentes, To Let Oneself Be Written

Interpretation: from Truth to Event

Éric Laurent, Interpretation: from Truth to Event

​

When Analysands Dream

Clotilde Leguil, Dreams and Nightmares: Index of Truth or Real?
Bénédicte Jullien, Getting the Words Out of My Mouth
Marta Serra Frediani, “The Dream Is an Awakening that Is Beginning”
Anne Béraud, The Dream: Index of Truth or of Real?
Clotilde Leguil,  Dream, Shoreline, Denouement

​

Politics: Dreaming in Another Language
Kholud Thabit-Sghayer, Plurality of Languages … Plurality of Homes
Ruzanna Hakobyan, Spoken Languages in the Analytic Cure
Peggy Papada, “[…] There Will Be Some Psychoanalyst Who Responds to Certain Subjective Emergencies”

​

Autopsy of an Interview
A Dialogue with Kenneth Goldsmith, Cheryl Donegan and The Lacanian Review

Editorial

Marie-Hélène Brousse & Cyrus Saint Amand Poliakoff

​

Writing the Real

Marie-Hélène Brousse, What’s Real? A Dialogue between Quantum Physicists and Psychoanalysts on Real and Matter

Matteo Barsuglia, Marie-Hélène Brousse & David Mabille, The Real and the Metaphoric in Physics

Catherine Pépin, Marie-Hélène Brousse & Philippe de Georges, The Perfection of the Void

Clotilde Leguil, Truth, Post-truth, Real

Philippe de Georges, What’s Worth Being Said: For Truth and the Real in Psychoanalysis

​

Ex-sist

Jacques-Alain Miller, The Pass of Psychoanalysis towards Science: The Desire for Knowledge

​

The Third

Jacques Lacan, The Third

​

Wefts and Knots: The Clinic of “The Third”

Marie-Hélène Brousse, Ordinary Psychosis

Dossia Avdelidi, Non-Triggerable Psychosis

Damien Guyonnet, On the Use of Verbal Hallucination

Jean-Luc Monnier,  Extension of the Domain of Feminine Jouissance

​

Truth & Fiction

Jacques-Alain Miller, The Lying Truth

Jacques-Alain Miller, Psychoanalysis, A Structure of Fiction

​

 Speaking A Real

Anne Béraud, The Amur of Amour

Bénédicte Jullien, Waiting for the Absent One

Aurélie Pfauwadel, The Traumas of Discord

​

Constructions

María Josefina Sota Fuentes, The Clinical Case: Interpretation and Transmission

Linda Clarke, A Kettle that Boils Over

Fouzia Taouzari, Being Mother at All Costs

​

Could be Worse . . . The Real of Politics

Martin Deleixhe, Pluralism and Political Uncertainties: Or Why Populists Increasingly Reject Both Migrants and Democracy

Jean-Claude Milner, Lacan’s Later Work and the Declaration of the Rights of Man

José Armando García, How Can Psychoanalysis Understand the Phenomenon of Populist Movements Today?

Janet Haney, The Disorder of the Day: Climate Change and the Capitalist Discourse

​

 For Real?

Elizabeth Rogers & Robert Buck, We’re Off the Deep End, Now

Catherine Massol, From Fine Letters to the Letter: The Tragedy of Hamlet or the Impossible Interpretation

François Ansermet, The Contemporary Body, Between Sense of Unease and Misunderstanding

Editorial

Marie-Hélène Brousse & Cyrus Saint Amand Poliakoff

​

THE REAL UNCONSCIOUS

Bernard SEYNHAEVE,

¡URGENT!

¡URGENCE!

Jacques LACAN,

Preface to the English Edition of Seminar XI

Préface à l’édition anglaise du Séminaire XI

Jacques-Alain MILLER,

The Real Unconscious

L’inconscient réel

Lee Edelman & Alicia Arenas, Psychoanalysis and Urgency: A Dialogue

​

URGENT CASES

Jacques-Alain MILLER,

The Space of a Lapsus

L’esp d’un lapsus

Jacques-Alain MILLER,

The Space of a Hallucination

L’esp d’une hallucination

Sonia Chiriaco, A Discreet Suture (*)

Marina Frangiadaki, A Nomination Faced with the Real of the Body (*)

Carolina Koretzky, From Indecision to In-Between (*)

​

SATISFACTION <> PASS

Jacques-Alain MILLER,

The Speaking Being and the Pass

La passe du parlêtre

Luis Erneta, Satisfaction in the “Preface”

Domenico Cosenza, Urgency and the Fall During Analysis

Patricia Tassara Zárate, From the Urgency of an Anxiety to the Urgency of a Satisfaction’s Bien-Dire

Laurent Dupont, The Urgency of the Analyst/Analysand

Maria Josefina Sota Fuentes, In Time

Anne Béraud, Different Urgencies

​

PSYCHOANALYSIS: A DELUSION…

Éric Laurent, Disruption of Jouissance in the Madnesses Under Transference

Véronique Voruz, Psychoanalysis: A Delusion not like the Others?

Véronique Voruz, Suggestion, Awakening, Dupery

Dominique Holvoet, Another Relation to the Real

Caroline Doucet, Fate of the Too-much in the Outrepass

Bénédicte Jullien, An Intermittent Solitude

​

LOGICAL TIME

Laura Sokolowsky, The Times of Analysis and its Real

Pascale Fari, The Cut and the Real of Time

Frank Rollier, The Cartel’s Urgency

Malka Shein, Two Comments on a Cartel

Nancy Gillespie, Resonance and the Difference Between Polysemy and the Equivoque

Shlomo Lieber, One (Un) Case

Serge Cottet, Side-track: Back to School

​

PAUSE

Angelina Harari, The Not-All Interview

Jorge Assef, The Push to Hypervelocity

Ricardo Seldes, PAUSA

Robert Buck, Pay Attention Mother Fuckers

(*) Published in the paper edition only

EDITORIAL

Marie-Hélène Brousse, Delights of the Ego?

THEMATIC SECTION: DELIGHTS OF THE EGO

​

RE-JOYCING THE EGO

Jacques Lacan, Joyce the Symptom

Éric Laurent, A Portrait of Joyce as a Saint Homme

Jacques Lacan, MIT Lecture on Topology

​

THE REIGN OF THE IMAGE

Jacques-Alain Miller, The Sovereign Image

Serge Cottet, Indelible Images Revisited

Jorge Assef, The Show of the Self in the Contemporary Symbolic Order

​

A POLITICS OF PSYCHOANALYSIS

Christiane Alberti, Life Choice

Laurent Dupont, Solitude and Action

Jean-Daniel Matet, Chronicle of a Disaster Foretold: Psychiatry in Ruins

Gérard Wajcman, Getting Involved

​

FORMATIONS OF THE ANALYST

Clotilde Leguil, ‘The First’

​

OUR ORIENTATION

Lilia Mahjoub, WAP – Year Zero 2018 General Meeting

​

THE INTERVIEW

Thomas Svolos, Lacan in America

EVENT: CLINICAL STUDY DAYS 11: DELIGHTS OF THE EGO

​

THE LACANIAN COMPASS IN THE UNITED STATES

Maria Cristina Aguirre and Nancy Gillespie, Editorial: The Lacanian Compass

in the United States

​

THEME AND OPENING REMARKS

Alicia Arenas, Theme

Lilia Mahjoub, Opening Remarks

​

THE UNCONSCIOUS IS POLITICS

Marie-Hélène Brousse, Democracies Without Fathers

Pierre-Gilles Guéguen, Me, Myself & I, That’s the Way the Song Goes

​

EGOMANIAS OF THE BODY

Domenico Cosenza, The Ego in Anorexia

Ellie Ragland, Nature Versus Nurture

Véronique Voruz, Love and the Ego

​

REFLECTING NEW NARCISSISMS

Marie-Hélène Brousse, The Consistency of the Imaginary: The Power of the Ego

Fabian Fajnwaks, The Triumph of Narcissism

Angelina Harari, “Be Yourself”: Delusion of Identity?

​

CLINICAL WORK

Jeff Erbe, Disappearing to Be Seen

Maria J. Lopez, The Case of “Me” Not a Zombie…

Cyrus Saint Amand Poliakoff, “Contouring”

Editorial

7          Marie-Hélène Brousse, Family Games

  THEMATIC SECTION: FAMILY DRAMAs, FAMILY TRAUMAs

Growing Pains

13       Jacques Lacan, Note on the Child

15        Daniel Roy, Introduction to “Note on the Child”

17       Véronique Eydoux, Destiny of the Emblem of the Intrusion Complex

23       Jacques-Alain Miller, In the Direction of Adolescence

34       Jacques-Alain Miller, Violent Children

43       Philippe Lacadée, How Do We Understand the Phenomena of Violence in Young People?

56       Anne Edan, “We do not Choose our Family” Some Orientations for Plural Practice in an Institution

     The Dialogue

61       Eva Illouz, The Dialogue: “Family Investments”

   New Knottings of Kith and Kin

73       Jacques-Alain Miller, Affairs of the Family in the Unconscious

78       Laura Sokolowsky, Freud, His Daughter, and the Other Woman

81       Christel Simler, Delphine Porcheron and Eugenia Caracciolo di Torella, What’s a Family in the Eyes of the Law?

98       Cyrus Saint Amand Poliakoff, Surrogate Mother(!)

101    François Ansermet, An Observatory Looking Out onto the Future of the Family

  New Publications in Our Field

105      François Ansermet, The Art of Making Children

108     Stijn Vanheule, A Lacanian Response to Issues in Psychiatric Diagnosis: An Interview with Stijn Vanheule

      Archive: Guattari on Dolto

113     Gary Genosko, Introduction to Félix Guattari, A Game of Scrabble with Lacan

117      Laura Sokolowsky, “You Do What I Theorise”

118     Félix Guattari, A Game of Scrabble with Lacan

          FORMATIONS OF THE ANALYST

124     Chantal Bonneau, The AMS: Partner-Symptom?

128     Dalia Arpin, Analytic Wings and Social Feet

Reductions

132     Caroline Doucet, The Recipe – 134 Fabian Fajnwaks, The Meanders of Jouissance – 136 Hélène Guilbaud, Losing a Child – 137 Jérôme Lecaux, Hatred Does Not Dissolve – 139 Dalila Arpin, A Slip of the Signature – 141 Laurent Dupont, Dream and Interpretation – An Experience in Solitude – 143 Dominique Holvoet, Explicit Signs of the End of an Analysis – 146 Daniel Pasqualin, Love and Mammography … Tracking Shot – 147 Véronique Voruz, “Shallow Tongue” – 149 Éric Laurent, The Outside Meaning: Between Sublimation and Corporisation

   CLINICAL WORK

156     Philippe Carpentier, The Weight of Words – “Berck”

160     Angelina Harari, Grandmothers Today

Our congresses

164     Lilia Mahjoub, In a State of Transference – Wild, Political, Psychoanalytic

174     Anna Aromí and Xavier Esqué, The Ordinary Psychoses and the Others, Under Transference

ADIEU

182     Serge Cottet, The Learning Years of Psychoanalysis

186     Christiane Alberti, Judith, The Cause Incarnate